Introduction
Falls through fragile materials, such as roof lights and
asbestos cement roofing sheets, account for more construction worker deaths
than any other single cause. According to the Health and Safety Executive,
almost one in five deaths in construction involve roofwork*. Furthermore, some
roofing methods require the use of heat which brings with it the potential for
personal injury and property fire incidents.
*http://www.hse.gov.uk/construction/safetytopics/roofwork.htm
This guide from ECIC explains some of the current materials
and application methods used in waterproofing and hotworks on roofs, the risks
associated with roofing work and the Health and Safety environment in which
roofers work today.
Waterproofing and Hot
Works
In the past, waterproofing of roofs was largely done with
bituminous felt roofing or asphalt with the application of heat to seal the
material. This type of roofing tends to
fall into two main types:
• Reinforced Bituminous membranes are
torch-on felts – this is where a polymer of modified bitumen is applied to the
membrane during the manufacturing process.
It is then torch applied at height, by the roofer using a gas
torch.
• Pour and roll is where boiling
bitumen is carried in a bucket to the roof.
It is then poured between two layers of roofing felt and the felt is
rolled out to bond the layers together.
Therefore the source of heat tends to be at ground level with the
inherent risk of transporting the boiling bitumen up on to the roof.
The development of both the materials used and techniques
for application have moved the industry forward towards safer installation
methods, eliminating the need for heat:
• Liquid membranes are cold applied
in a built up system usually incorporating a carrier membrane. They don’t require any heat for sealing but
can be difficult to install in cold damp conditions.
• Alternatively, Single Ply membranes
are lightweight polymer sheers of membrane.
The sheets are sealed at joints to form continuous waterproofing. This
roofing solution offers safer, flame-free construction using hot-air welding,
adhesives and fasteners.
The fact remains however, that despite these advances, the
risks to property and people are still very present.
The Property
Insurance implications
Looking first at the risks of damage to property,
historically the insurance sector has suffered from significant losses related
to roofing work – both to the property on which work is being conducted and
those neighbouring.
The main causes for these losses have been:
• The
property being worked has not been properly protected from the elements
• Poor
quality roofing work and/or design resulting in damage from winds, rain, storm
etc.
• Leaking
roofs causing damage to property
• Damage to property caused by fires
when inadequate risk management in respect of Hot Works, due to inadequate
identification and management of combustible materials
How the Insurance
sector manages its exposures to Hot Works risks
In respect of fires caused by Hot Works, Insurers will
commonly manage their exposures by imposing a Hot Work/Fire Precautions
Condition as a warranty precedent to liability.
These conditions outline the minimum standards an Insured
should be able to demonstrate that they work to when using the application of
heat. Whilst these conditions are not standardised across the industry they
typically include the following requirements:
• A
definition of the appliances they relate to
• Best
practice use of equipment including risk management controls
• A
thorough examination of the roof work and immediate vicinity prior to work
commencing
• Identification,
removal and protection of combustible materials
• Adequate
fire extinguishers to be present
• Specified timescales after the
application of heat when a thorough examination of the work and vicinity should
take place.
• Where hot works cannot be
undertaken in a safe way to prevent injury or damage to property, alternative
methods of roofing should always be used.
Precautions Conditions are usually set out clearly as part
of a Public and Products Liability cover wording.
Supporting Roofing
Worker Safety
From a Health and Safety perspective, there are a number of
regulations, codes of practice, HSE guidance notes and principles that exist to
protect worker safety, with the Health and Safety at Work Act of 1974 at their
core. The most recent of these is
Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015.
The CDM 2015 sets out responsibilities for contractors,
workers and Principle contractors which apply to all aspects of construction
work, including roofing:
Contractor’s responsibilities
• Prepare
and update the construction phase plan
• Plan,
monitor and manage their work
• Provide an
induction
• Provide
welfare facilities and secure the site
• Co-operate
and co-ordinate
Workers’
responsibilities
• Care for
own health and safety and that of others
• Co-operate
with others
• Report
any concerns
• Engage in
consultation
Principle contractor’s
responsibilities
• Prepare
and update the construction phase plan
• Plan,
monitor and manage their work
• Provide
an induction
• Provide
welfare facilities and secure the site
• Contractor
co-operation and co-ordination
• Consult
workforce
• Issue the
health and safety file
Designer’s
Responsibilities
• Eliminate
or reduce control risks
• Provide
information
• Issue
relevant information for health and safety file
• Design
our risks in future construction
Client
responsibilities
• Management
arrangements and welfare
• Appoint a
principal designer and principle contractor
• Ensure
appointees have the knowledge, skills and experience
• Provide
information and notify the HSE (F10)
• CDM 2015
doesn't require domestic clients to carry out client duties
Principal Designers
• Plan,
monitor, manage and co-ordinate health and safety in pre-construction phase
• Identify,
eliminate or control risk
• Ensure
designer DCM performance
• Manage
pre-construction information
• Ensure
the principal contractors has all the information needed
• Prepare
and issue the health and safety file
In association with ECIC